Skip to content
HarvestBench

Container gardening

Pots split two ways: material (plastic, ceramic, fabric) and volume in gallons (1, 3, 5, 7, 10, and up). Material changes watering. Gallons change which plant will finish a crop.

Fill containers with potting mix, not garden soil. Start with the potting mix calculator so you buy bags once. Nursery “#5” plastic pots can hold less than a 5-gallon bucket or grow bag — measure if the plant looks cramped.

Recommended calculator

Pot materials

Fabric grow bags are the nonwoven bags sold in gallon sizes. Ceramic includes unglazed terracotta (dries fast) and glazed pots (hold water more like plastic).

Plastic

Light, cheap, holds moisture

Best for: Herbs, lettuce, and anything that hates drying out on a hot patio

Advantages

  • Light enough to move on a balcony
  • Inexpensive, and nursery pots are easy to find
  • Holds water longer than fabric or unglazed clay

Tradeoffs

  • Can overheat in full sun on a dark pot
  • Cheap pots get brittle after a few winters
  • No air pruning — roots may circle if the pot is too small

Check two inches down. Plastic stays wet longer than fabric after the same rain.

Ceramic

Heavy, decorative; terracotta dries faster than glazed

Best for: Herbs and peppers you will not drag around; glazed pots for plants that want even moisture

Advantages

  • Stable in wind — less tipping than a light grow bag
  • Looks finished on a porch
  • Unglazed terracotta breathes, which herbs like rosemary and thyme often prefer

Tradeoffs

  • Heavy once filled — hard to move
  • Can crack in a hard freeze if left wet outdoors
  • Unglazed clay dries fast in heat; glazed clay holds water more like plastic

Terracotta needs more frequent water than plastic. Glazed ceramic is closer to plastic.

Fabric (grow bag)

Nonwoven bag; air-prunes roots, dries fast

Best for: Tomatoes, peppers, and potatoes when you can water often, or in a humid climate

Advantages

  • Air pruning reduces circling roots
  • Light, folds for winter storage
  • Sold in honest-ish gallon sizes (1, 3, 5, 7, 10, 15, 20)

Tradeoffs

  • Dries out fast in sun and wind — the usual summer failure
  • Can sag if the mix is too wet and heavy
  • Needs a tray or saucer on a deck so it does not stain

Expect to water more often than plastic. Mulch the surface. Do not use garden soil — it packs in fabric.

Gallon sizes

Smaller than 1 gallon is fine for seedlings and a single herb. Larger than 20 gallons starts to act like a small raised bed.

Typical crops for common pot sizes
Pot sizeA reasonable crop
1 galBasil, parsley, thyme, chives, lettuce, green onions
3 galPeppers, chard, kale, bush beans, a patio / determinate tomato
5 galDeterminate tomato, eggplant, trellised cucumber, a comfortable pepper
7 galA larger tomato, two peppers, or a compact zucchini
10 galIndeterminate tomato with a cage, potatoes in a grow bag
15 galIndeterminate tomato that you intend to keep all season
20 galA small patio mix, or potatoes you will hill as they grow

Which plant in which pot

Comfortable sizes for a full season — not the smallest pot a seedling will survive in. One plant per pot for tomatoes, peppers, eggplant, cucumber, and zucchini.

Vegetable and herb container sizes
PlantPot sizeMaterialNotes
Herbs (basil, parsley, cilantro)1–2 galPlastic or glazed ceramicOne plant per small pot, or a 3-gal mix of three herbs. Cilantro bolts in heat — afternoon shade helps.
Thyme, rosemary, oregano1–3 galTerracotta or fabricThey like the mix to dry a little. A constantly soggy plastic pot is the usual kill.
Lettuce, spinach, green onions1–3 galPlasticShallow roots. A wide bowl works. Keep even moisture so leaves do not turn bitter.
Peppers3–5 galPlastic or fabricOne plant. 5 gal is more comfortable in heat. Do not crowd two peppers in a 3-gal bag.
Determinate / patio tomato5 gal minimumFabric or plasticCage or stake. A 3-gal pot will fruit, then stall in July.
Indeterminate tomato10–15 galFabric grow bagNeeds a real cage. 5 gal is too small for a full-season vine on a patio.
Eggplant5 galBlack plastic (warm roots)One plant. Heat lovers like a pot that warms; do not let it cook dry.
Cucumber5 galFabric or plasticOne plant, trellis behind the pot. Bush types are easier than long vines.
Bush beans3–5 galPlasticSeveral plants in a wide pot. Pole beans need a trellis and more mix.
Kale, chard3–5 galPlastic or fabricOne or two plants. Deep enough that summer heat does not cook the roots.
Zucchini / summer squash7–10 galFabricOne plant only. These are thirsty and sprawl. A 5-gal pot is usually too small.
Potatoes10 gal grow bagFabricStart with a few inches of mix, hill as vines grow. Do not use a sealed ceramic crock with no drainage.
CarrotsDeep 3–5 galPlastic (deep)Depth matters more than gallons. Need a loose column; skip fat terracotta bowls.
Strawberries3 gal or a wide planterPlastic or fabricWide and shallow beats a tall skinny pot. Refresh mix after a couple of seasons.

Guides